| Name | Position | Years |
|---|---|---|
| Jeremiah Ieremia | LB | 2018 |
| Mekeli Ieremia | DT | 1974-77 |
| Tevita Ika | WR | 2019-21 |
| Orval Ikelberry | HB | 1931 |
| Cook Ili | FB | 1981 |
| Earl Imboden | T | 1946 |
| George Imboden | QB | 1946 |
| Franco Improta | LB | 2007 |
| Adam Ingersoll | DL | 2013-15 |
| Grant Ingersoll | E | 1928 |
| Eric Ingersoll | DT | 1976 |
| Fisher Ingersoll | WR | 2026 |
| Floyd Irish | OL | 1969 |
| Tai Irish | RB | |
| Eric Iverson | WR | 2000 |