Lists
AP All-Americans
| Season | Player |
|---|---|
| 1962 | Eldon Fortie |
| 1971 | Gordon Gravelle |
| 1975 | Brad Oates |
| 1976 | Gifford Nielsen |
| 1980 | Jim McMahon |
| 1981 | Jim McMahon |
| 1988 | Pat Thompson |
| 1994 | Evan Pilgrim |
| 1999 | Rob Morris |
| 2004 | Matt Payne |
| 2023 | Dallin Holker |
| 2025 | John Henry Daley |